Nate Silver: prediction track record

Founder of FiveThirtyEight, now writes Silver Bulletin

Credibility 54% Coin flip 10 years half-life
All-time
58%no decay
Resolved
6
Right
3
Wrong
3
Brier score
0.29coin flip 0.25
Last resolved
5 Nov 2024

Credibility half-life

Nate Silver: credibility half-life chartCredibility of Nate Silver from 6 May 2008 to 14 Oct 2026, with a 10 years half-life. 6 resolved predictions marked on the line. Now 54%.0%25%50%75%100%20102015202020254 Nov 2008: Barack Obama wins the 2008 presidential election. (right)6 Nov 2012: Barack Obama wins re-election in 2012. (right)19 Jul 2016: Donald Trump does not win the 2016 Republican nomination. (wrong)8 Nov 2016: Hillary Clinton wins the 2016 presidential election. (wrong)3 Nov 2020: Joe Biden wins the 2020 presidential election. (right)5 Nov 2024: Kamala Harris wins the 2024 presidential election. (wrong)54%coin flip

Scored 14 Oct 2026. How the score works

Resolved predictions

PredictionMadeResolvedOutcomeEffect on score

Kamala Harris wins the 2024 presidential election.

Stated chance 50%

Silver Bulletin's final model had Harris winning 40,012 of 80,000 simulations, effectively a coin flip.

Source: 2024 United States presidential election (Wikipedia)

Wrong 55% → 54% (−0.9 pts)

Joe Biden wins the 2020 presidential election.

Stated chance 89%

Final FiveThirtyEight forecast: Biden favoured in 89 of 100 simulations.

Source: 2020 United States presidential election (Wikipedia)

Right 49% → 56% (+7.3 pts)

Hillary Clinton wins the 2016 presidential election.

Stated chance 71.4%

Final FiveThirtyEight forecast gave Clinton a 71.4% chance, higher uncertainty than most other models.

Source: 2016 United States presidential election (Wikipedia)

Wrong 53% → 48% (−4.6 pts)

Donald Trump does not win the 2016 Republican nomination.

Stated chance 98%

Silver put Trump's chances at about 2%, a judgement he later said was not model-based and called a mistake.

Source: Nate Silver got Donald Trump all wrong, and he knows it (Bustle)

Wrong 68% → 53% (−15.2 pts)

Barack Obama wins re-election in 2012.

Stated chance 90.9%

Final forecast gave Obama a 90.9% chance and called all 50 states correctly.

Source: Nate Silver (Wikipedia)

Right 64% → 71% (+7.2 pts)

Barack Obama wins the 2008 presidential election.

The final FiveThirtyEight map also called 49 of 50 states correctly, missing Indiana.

Source: 2008 United States presidential election (Wikipedia)

Right 50% → 67% (+16.7 pts)

Atom feed of Nate Silver's resolutions · Compare with another figure · Report an error or a missing prediction